[rspec-users] given-when-then-and syntax support in Rspec

Rodrigo Rosenfeld Rosas lbocseg at yahoo.com.br
Sat Mar 26 22:43:21 EDT 2011

Hi David and fellows,

I know this subject has already been discussed here and there are 
already some attempts to support the given-when-then-and syntax in 
Rspec, like the links below:


First, I don't understand the reason to adopt the capital method names 
Given/When/Then/And instead of given/when/then/and. Then, I don't think 
we can call this some real support for that syntax because "example" is 
not meant to be executed in any special order in Rspec nor it can be 
defined that any additional "then/and" should be aborted if a prior 
expectation wasn't met. And both solutions seem to work by simple 
aliasing "example" and "describe".

I never used Cucumber because I find that working with it is cumbersome 
for most cases.

I've been working mostly with Grails on my daily job for about 2 years 
now since I moved to my current job. I wanted something like Rspec for 
Groovy and Grails and while searching for some alternative, I found EasyB:


Actually I liked the story syntax they provide as well as the reports 
and I found it would be useful for Rspec to incorporate that style too:


What do you think?

Best regards!


More information about the rspec-users mailing list