blowmage at gmail.com
Fri Oct 22 23:26:30 EDT 2010
On Fri, Oct 22, 2010 at 6:59 PM, Tomas Matousek <
Tomas.Matousek at microsoft.com> wrote:
> 2) It is not a holdover. It makes a lot of sense actually for at least
> the following reasons:
> a) Some IronRuby tests test interop between these languages. So there is a
> direct dependency. When you debug issues in language interop you need to
> have IronPython source code as well to step thru and make sense of the
I don't understand why the code needs to exist within the same git repo for
this then. Can you not have a Visual Studio solution that includes multiple
projects with their own repository? Can't you have your automated build
system pull both the IronRuby and IronPython projects to run the integration
> b) DLR has two parts – the “inner ring” that shipped in .NET Framework
> 4.0 and the “outer ring”, which hasn’t shipped. Although the outer ring is
> pretty stable there are still many improvements that can/should be done.
> Obviously when you change the DLR you should run tests for both languages so
> that you don’t break anything. Thus IronPython’s test suite in the repo is
> handy. Also, if you change public API in the outer ring you might need to
> change both IronPython and IronRuby. All of this could be done in stages
> across different repos and even source control systems, but that’s obviously
> much more complicated than having it just work.
I assumed the DLR was fixed. If that is not the case then shouldn't the DLR
should be its own separate git repo as well?
Is size of the repo really an issue? If not, what is?
No, its not the size of the repo, rather the amount of tangental code. As
someone who hasn't looked at the code for well over a year, I am struck by
the amount of orthogonal concerns that are front and center. I find it too
busy and off-putting as a developer looking to become familiar with the code
or make a small contribution. I don't doubt there aren't reasons it is the
way it is, just that it can be better if you want to really open the
floodgates of contributions.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Ironruby-core